As a former newspaper reporter, I’m trying to figure out why stark evidence that Bashar Al Assad’s Syrian regime systematically starved, tortured and killed roughly 11,000 men who were, effectively, prisoners of war hasn’t gotten more play.
The German Spiegel hit it hard as did the London Guardian and CNN, the two outlets originally fed the story and, I assume, the 26,000 digital photos backing it up. The New York Times, though, is more interested in their snowstorm, apparently. They buried it their The Lede blog. Seems like I managed to dig something up from the Washington Post earlier today but can’t seem to find it now, so buried it is.
No question that the Qataris, opponents of the regime, paid for the London-based law firm investigating the atrocity (a military-police defector they’re calling “Caesar” provided the images). Caesar was charged with photographing the dead streaming out of Assad’s prisons, presumably to ensure that Assad’s security services didn’t let the prisoners go.
They were identified using a number system, hinting at industrial-scale killing. Caesar saved off, by his account, 55,000 images, of which he was able to get about half out of the country, it seems. Most of dead were men between the ages of 20 and 40 years of age, investigators believe. Many show signs of torture and a majority look to have been starved, the investigators say. The report has an appendix of photos of emaciated dead with wicked bruises and lacerations. The Guardian reported today that these murdered detainees could be just the tip of the iceberg – that the same thing may be happening in other regions.
This is a bigger story as Iran being snubbed in the second round of Syrian peace talks, even if America’s leading newspapers don’t seem to think so. Because if the images tell a true story, the world, sans Iran, will be negotiating with a true butcher in Geneva.
Addendum, Jan. 23, 2014: The New York Times ran a very good piece on Jan. 23, titled State Dept. Learned in November of Photos Said to Show Torture in Syria, advancing the initial story rather than just repeating it. It quotes Secretary of State John Kerry as saying, “The questions raised by this require an answer [….] I can’t tell you exactly what all of it is except that I know that they are people who have suffered egregious torture and death.” White House Spokesman Jay Carney followed with: “These photos cannot be ignored or dismissed. They suggest widespread and apparently systematic violations of international human law and demonstrate just how far the regime is willing to go in harming its own people. They’re very disturbing images.” So kudos to the Gray Lady.
20 Comments
The President’s ‘reset’ with Russia might be a factor….it’d put him in a tough place. That and maybe because it’s an issue that all Americans could be united on…unfortunately, issues that divide us seem get the most press.
War fatigue. What can we do about this admittedly terrible situation? In truth, very little. Perhaps if we hadn’t spent the past 10 years embroiled in a pointless war of choice in Iraq we might have the stomach for intervention, but not at this time.
Wag, yeah, true. These kinds of revelations, if they get the attention they deserve, could steer whatever negotiated settlement comes out of this quagmire, though.
Wag, yeah, true. These kinds of revelations, if they get the attention they deserve, could steer whatever negotiated settlement comes out of this quagmire, though. https://toddneff.com/?p=664#comment-1739
They can only steer us through a quagmire it there’s a credible threat of US intervention to back it up. I don’t think that’s an option.
Øivind Moldestad liked this on Facebook.
2 cents from someone too far removed to speak to all the facts, but my take on it Todd is that we engaged on Syria because they broke the international rule on Chemical Weapons….of course, we later backed out…….The US, regardless of whether it is Africa, Iraq, China, N Korea or Syria does not care enough to “engage” just becuse leaders kill thousands of innocent people, but will engage to make a point on breaking international rule and/or if we feel the leader/country is a threat and/or if there is monetary opportunity for US. Sad but true. We learn and teach in our schools that we engaged in Vietnam or Korea or Europe to be the great liberators and guardians of freedom, but we only engaged because in each of those cases, the US leaders were concerned about that threat to the US. That’s my 2 cents as to why the US has not engaged……no for my cynical liberal press bash comment…..I think the US media pretty much supports the left and if they pressed this issue, or similar issues in Africa, it would make Obama look bad. I’d bet Hannity or O’Reilly covered this to some degree, but I could be wrong. Another theory is this….kind of like the earlier comments….US readers (in large part) do not want to read about these atrocities….does not sell ad space, readership, etc…….and while the media likes to beat up on politicians for only engaging when it’s about money, it’s rather ironic, because money drives the decisions of the media in very much the same way……
I don’t get it, either, except the fact that Americans continue to be uninterested in the rest of the world, and our media give us what we want.
The US has lost it’s moral compass. Our drones kill innocents, Guantanamo, etc.
And with that Americans are numb.
Kevin Newman liked this on Facebook.
It’s not often one gets such a wide array of political perspectives in a FB comment section and agrees with what everybody said.
I wish the world were simple
On a personal level, I’m tired. Tired of being outraged at things out of my control. Wondering if it’s age (44 and counting) or part of something in the zeitgeist.
There are no good guys in this mess in Syria. In that case, so long as the bad guys aren’t going to turn around and fly planes into our buildings, what they do to each other is not our concern. For better or worse, I think most Americans feel that way.
Eric Meyers liked this on Facebook.
Susan Suhye Shin liked this on Facebook.
I think you’re right, Matt and media is reflecting that, though the NYT did have a couple stories on the peace negotiations today.
Chris Young liked this on Facebook.
Shinichiro Takagi liked this on Facebook.
Comments are closed.